Chapter 1: Julie’s Letter
Dear Ate Charo,
This story is about an unfinished chapter in my life that, up until now, still has no ending story. The angst of that “what if” question still haunts me and I never realized how much it has affected my life until a friend of mine unconsciously re-opened that chapter. I don’t know if this letter will give it an ending but just writing this gave me a certain sense of relief, although not enough to give a feeling of comfort and contentment.
Chapter 2: The Surprise Meeting
“Maribel, Annette, and I were having coffee in a popular coffee shop while waiting for Annette’s friend, whom she was supposed to meet around 9PM. While chatting and browsing some pictures that Annette brought, I saw my college friend, who I have never seen for quite a long time, walking towards our table. Apparently, the person we were waiting for was her, Roxie. Just a few minutes of surprised and excited discussion about this fine co-incidence, and next thing we knew, Roxie was reminiscing my past ‘love life’.
Chapter 3: Remembering Elmer
“Elmer and I became friends when we were in our 3rd year in college. I really don’t know how it happened, but from being plain classmates we suddenly found ourselves spending time with each other even if there is no more school work to talk about. We talk about each other’s personal life so candidly that before long, we knew each other like we have been friends for life. We were so close that I even became friends with his brother and was spending a lot of time at their house even if we do not have ‘overnight sessions’. We were so close that everybody around us, our classmates, instructors, even our parents and close relatives, think that we were romantically involved with each other already. But between us, we know that we were just friends, close friends, and nothing more. However, with everything that has happened between us, I just can’t help thinking about the probability that there might be more to us than just friends. I’m a very loving (thoughtful and caring according to Elmer) person and loving him isn’t really hard considering where we are already.
Chapter 4: The Signs
“I kept dismissing the thought that he might take a different look at our relationship, but there are a lot of signs that my girl friends see, which I never really thought of at first, but gave me ideas when presented to me in a ‘malicious’ way.
- He spends more time with me than with his ‘barkada’
- We talk about very personal things about each other
- He confided to me that our relationship is ‘deeper’ compared to his relationship with his girlfriend (yes he had a girlfriend but it was a long distance relationship) and that our time together was more substantial compared to theirs
- He was willing to stick it out with me despite the irritating jokes made by our classmates regarding our relationship
“Even our common friends, Roxie and Jun, kept telling me that there must be something more between us but neither Elmer nor I were brave enough to open up that issue to each other.
Chapter 5: Letters and Jun
“When we graduated, Elmer immediately went to US to live with his parents, and at long last be with his girlfriend who left for the US a few months after she became his girlfriend We kept in touch through letters twice a month at the very least. Those letters kept him happy and sane despite his monotonous quiet unemployed life which almost drove him crazy. Later on, he got busy with some extra curricular activities, but the letters kept coming. I was already working then and me and Jun are officemates. I showed him Elmer’s letters and he was quick to note some lines which he believes are signs that Elmer is trying to fish for info regarding my feelings about him. The following letters showed more signs, as seen by Jun, that slowly, I started to think that maybe he really was trying to push our friendship to a deeper form of relationship especially after Elmer said that he had already broken up with his girlfriend..
“I don’t know if Jun was just envious of how cheesy were getting to be, but he suddenly courted me. For a long time, I was convinced that Jun has a different sexual preference – let’s be blunt about it – he’s gay. But when he told me that he loved me, I believed him. Maybe I missed Elmer so much that I became so vulnerable to his words. Maybe I trusted him so much because he is my friend and would never joke about something so serious especially at that time when I am so confused. I accepted him.
“I wrote to Elmer about it. I forced myself to ask him about where our relationship is going because I want to give Jun and myself a chance. He politely told me that ours is a special relationship that will remain as that and nothing more. Only 2 more letters came after that. Until now, we have not communicated. Well, we (my husband (not Jun) and I) did visit him when he went home a few years after. We were very civil with each other, but other than that, no more communications. He does not even answer my emails.
Chapter 6: My Bad
“My relationship with Jun did not last long (Ha-ha-ha… What can you expect?). Obviously it was a mistake for me to believe that he was not what I thought he was. Up to now I still can’t get over the fact that I trusted him. Up to now I still can’t get over the fact that Jun knowingly used me in my most vulnerable state just to prove something to the people around him.
“I don’t know if it would have been the same if I did not tell Elmer about Jun and me when I asked him about our relationship. But the more I thought about his past letters and that one where he said that we’re just friends, the more I thought that he just told that for the sake of his friendship with Jun. Would he have said the same thing if I did not tell him about Jun and me? I guess I will never know.
“It’s my fault. Maybe Elmer was really trying to drive our relationship to a higher level. I got impatient. (Well, what can you expect from somebody who never had a boyfriend before the age of 22?) I took matters in my own hand, instead of just going with the flow. Or maybe he just miss our happy days together? I really don’t know.
Chapter 7: What If?
“After 13 years, that question, buried deeply under happy memoirs of my married life, suddenly re-surfaced. I guess, what Elmer and I had was so special that it can never be drowned by 11 happy years of married life. Although now, I consider it only a hypothetical question, sometimes it still makes me stop and think about what would have happened had I not asked him that question. Would I be in the US now with Elmer? Or would I still be married to my current husband? It would be nice to find out the answer and finally give an ending to that chapter of my life.
Always,
Julie